Topic > Who Killed William in 'Frankenstein': Creature vs. Creator

The death of William Frankenstein in Mary Shelley's Frankenstein creates a question: "Who killed William in Frankenstein? The creature or his creator, Victor ?" This question is why we are here today. Victor is the creator of the monster and can be blamed for not being responsible and letting the creature go free, but also for possessing the secret to creating life, as the story goes continues, we can clearly see many different pieces of evidence that show that the monster is to blame Even though Victor has abandoned the monster since his creation, the monster is the one to blame because he was the one who physically killed William. Not only did the monster kill William , but we can also deduce that he is also responsible for the death of Justine. It becomes obvious that Victor is not the one to blame as the monster has a clear conscience and knew that what he had done was wrong. Now it is your job as a jury to convict this creature of murdering innocent and defenseless victims to plagiarism. Get a custom essay on “Why Violent Video Games Should Not Be Banned” Get an Original Essay Who Killed William in “Frankenstein”? Who can we blame for this? Although many people would blame Victor for never loving the monster or not paying enough attention to him, when we compare the two, we can see that the creature did much worse. But Victor is not entirely innocent. The defense can argue that Victor should not have created the creature because he had found a forbidden secret in the first place and had devoted many hours to creating a secret experiment. If you think from Victor's point of view, he was traumatized by his mother's sudden death and seeing something as grotesque as the monster, wouldn't you be scared too? On the other hand, Victor was irresponsible, as he shows when he says: "Unable to bear the appearance of the being I had created, I ran out of the room and continued for a long time across my bedroom, unable to bring myself to sleep." . ”. Soon after the creature was brought back to life, Victor was traumatized and horrified by its appearance. He quickly realized this was a mistake and separated from his family and friends. Of course, he immediately regretted his decision while the creature regretted nothing even after killing people. But Victor is a human being and all human beings make mistakes. The difference between Victor's mistake is completely different from that of the Creatures because the Creatures were also an intentional murder with a plan to hide it. We can see this when the creature says: “The child struggled (referring to William) and burdened me with epithets that brought despair to my heart; I grabbed his throat to 'shut him up' and in an instant he was lying dead at my feet. I looked at the victim and my heart swelled with exultation and infernal triumph; clapping your hands." The fact that the monster killed a child and described it as "shushing" him and "clapping" his hands in "triumph" as if it were a victory is disgusting and I'm sure anyone can see that. Soon after, he took the portrait from the deceased child's body and placed it in Justine's pocket. This covered up his murder by showing how intelligent the creature is and how he planned an attack whose consequences he avoided. The defense attorney may try to convince you to believe that it's all Victor's fault and I'll leave the decision up to you. However, keep in mind the fine line between an accident and an intentional wrongdoing such as the complex murder committed by the creature. The creature is guilty of William's murder and Justine's execution. Although Victor had abandoned the Creature since.